Dove “AirBrush” Controversy Misses the Point
Tuesday, May 13th, 2008Real women are always informed on salient issues, so on the off chance you’ve missed the controversy regarding the Dove “campaign for real beauty” I thought I’d, dare I say, weigh in on it.
Dove is a brand belonging to the Unilever Company, a multi-national consumer products company. Unilever manufactures products ranging from tea to mayonnaise, including deodorants, ice cream, diet and skin care products, soup, detergents, etc., etc. You have Unilever brands on your shelves, in your refrigerator and in your bath and laundry rooms.
In 2004, in concert with its advertising firm Ogilvy and Mather, Dove launched its real beauty campaign aimed at “inspiring women to enjoy their own beauty and individuality.” Two overall strategies underpin the campaign. First, the use of “real women” in its advertising and the source of the controversy and second, the Dove Self Esteem Fund aimed at teens and young girls.
The controversy developed after a celebrity photo re-toucher, Pascal Dangin, asserted in The New Yorker this month that he’d airbrushed the pictures of the “real beauties” used in the advertising.
This has struck a nerve, apparently a deep one, and hundreds, if not thousands, of articles have been written about the possibility that Dangin airbrushed the tushes, thighs and boobs of the women in the ads who are pictured grinning broadly in identical sparkling white bras and panties.
My own callow reaction is “Who cares?” I know I’d want my tush airbrushed if I was going to appear on a billboard in my underwear.
Far more troubling is the Dove Self Esteem Fund aimed at reaching “the lives of five million young people by the end of 2010 with at least one hour of participation in our self-esteem programs.”
The notion that parents would actually encourage their children to spend an hour participating in a program developed by the beauty industry, the same industry by the way that Dove is castigating in its campaign, is not only ridiculous, it’s a little scary. (And do any of these people concerned with the airbrushing issue recognize the hypocrisy of this campaign?)
But the company claims results. Dove says it’s reached over three million kids with its self-esteem programs, a fact much more alarming than any airbrushing Dangin may or may not have done.
Do we really want the giants of global industry developing self-esteem programs for our children? Do we want them developing any programs at all for our kids?
Nope. Not me. Not ever.